-How to avoid frequent and blocking Memstore Flushes? (was: Re: About HBase Memstore Flushes)
I have a feeling Alex is raising an important issue, but maybe it's not getting attention because it's tl;dr?
Andy Purtell just wrote something very related in a different thread:
> "The amount of heap alloted for memstore is fixed by configuration.
> HBase maintains this global limit as part of a strategy to avoid out
> of memory conditions. Therefore, as the number of regions grow, the
> available space for each region's memstore shrinks proportionally. If
> you have a heap sized too small for region hosting demand, then when
> the number of regions gets up there, HBase will be flushing constantly
> tiny files and compacting endlessly."
So isn't the above a problem for anyone using HBase? More precisely, this part:
"...when the number of regions gets up there, HBase will be flushing constantly tiny files and compacting endlessly."
If this is not a problem, how do people work around this? Somehow keep the number of regions mostly constant, or...?
Performance Monitoring for Solr / ElasticSearch / HBase - http://sematext.com/spm
> From: Alex Baranau <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>Sent: Wednesday, May 9, 2012 6:02 PM
>Subject: Re: About HBase Memstore Flushes
>Should I may be create a JIRA issue for that?
>Sematext :: http://blog.sematext.com/
>On Tue, May 8, 2012 at 4:00 PM, Alex Baranau <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:
>> Just trying to check that I understand things correctly about configuring
>> memstore flushes.
>> Basically, there are two groups of configuraion properties (leaving out
>> region pre-close flushes):
>> 1. determines when flush should be triggered
>> 2. determines when flush should be triggered and updates should be blocked
>> during flushing
>> 2nd one is for safety reasons: we don't want memstore to grow without a
>> limit, so we forbid writes unless memstore has "bearable" size. Also we
>> don't want flushed files to be too big. These properties are:
>> * hbase.regionserver.global.memstore.upperLimit &
>> hbase.regionserver.global.memstore.lowerLimit  (1)
>> * hbase.hregion.memstore.block.multiplier 
>> 1st group (sorry for reverse order) is about triggering "regular flushes".
>> As flushes can be performed without pausing updates, we want them to happen
>> before conditions for "blocking updates" flushes are met. The property for
>> configuring this is
>> * hbase.hregion.memstore.flush.size 
>> (* there are also open jira issues for per colfam settings)
>> As we don't want to perform too frequent flushes, we want to keep this
>> option big enough to avoid that. At the same time we want to keep it small
>> enough so that it triggers flushing *before* the "blocking updates"
>> flushing is triggered. This configuration is per-region, while (1) is per
>> regionserver. So, if we had constant (more or less) number of regions per
>> regionserver, we could choose the value in a such way that it is not too
>> small, but small enough. However it is usual situation when regions number
>> assigned to regionserver varies a lot during cluster life. And we don't
>> want to adjust it over time (which requires RSs restarts).
>> Does thinking above make sense to you? If yes, then here are the questions:
>> A. is it a goal to have more or less constant regions number per
>> regionserver? Can anyone share their experience if that is achievable?
>> B. or should there be any config options for setting up triggering flushes
>> based on regionserver state (not just individual regions or stores)? E.g.:
>> B.1 given setting X%, trigger flush of biggest memstore (or whatever
>> is logic for selecting memstore to flush) when memstore takes up X% of heap
>> (similar to (1), but triggers flushing when there's no need to block
>> updates yet)
>> B.2 any other which takes into account regions number
>> Alex Baranau