Matt Fellows 2013-08-15, 12:31
Andrew Wang 2013-08-15, 18:50
Todd Lipcon 2013-08-15, 21:17
Colin McCabe 2013-08-20, 19:42
Colin McCabe 2013-08-20, 19:43
Thanks for the heads up, but I think I've managed to implement it crudely by overwriting sequentially with 1s, 0s and random bytes and tested it successfully on an ext4 partition.
I tested it by dd-ing the entire partition to a file, confirming a particular string was not present with strings, uploaded a large file with a chosen string repeated in it many times, dd'd the partition to confirm it was present, issued a delete, repeated the test and confirmed it had been removed.
I'm sure some journal information may be leaked, but the entire block can't be reconstructed from the journal else your disk would be halved in useable size right?
Sent from Mailbox for iPhone
On Tue, Aug 20, 2013 at 8:43 PM, Colin McCabe <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> If I've got the right idea about this at all?
> From the man page for wipe(1);
> "Journaling filesystems (such as Ext3 or ReiserFS) are now being used by
> default by most Linux distributions. No secure deletion program that does
> filesystem-level calls can sanitize files on such filesystems, because
> sensitive data and metadata can be written to the journal, which cannot be
> readily accessed. Per-file secure deletion is better implemented in the
> operating system."
> You might be able to work around this by turning off the journal on these
> filesystems. But even then, you've got issues like the drive remapping bad
> sectors (and leaving around the old ones), flash firmware that is unable to
> erase less than an erase block, etc.
> The simplest solution is probably just to use full-disk encryption. Then
> you don't need any code changes at all.
> Doing something like invoking shred on the block files could improve
> security somewhat, but it's not going to work all the time.
> On Thu, Aug 15, 2013 at 5:31 AM, Matt Fellows <
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>> I'm looking into writing a patch for HDFS which will provide a new method
>> within HDFS which can securely delete the contents of a block on all the
>> nodes upon which it exists. By securely delete I mean, overwrite with
>> 1's/0's/random data cyclically such that the data could not be recovered
>> I'm not currently aware of any existing code / methods which provide this,
>> so was going to implement this myself.
>> I figured the DataNode.java was probably the place to start looking into
>> how this could be done, so I've read the source for this, but it's not
>> really enlightened me a massive amount.
>> I'm assuming I need to tell the NameServer that all DataNodes with a
>> particular block id would be required to be deleted, then as each DataNode
>> calls home, the DataNode would be instructed to securely delete the
>> relevant block, and it would oblige.
>> Unfortunately I have no idea where to begin and was looking for some
>> I guess specifically I'd like to know:
>> 1. Where the hdfs CLI commands are implemented
>> 2. How a DataNode identifies a block / how a NameServer could inform a
>> DataNode to delete a block
>> 3. Where the existing "delete" is implemented so I can make sure my secure
>> delete makes use of it after successfully blanking the block contents
>> 4. If I've got the right idea about this at all?
>> Kind regards,
>> Matt Fellows
>> [image: cid:1CBF4038-3F0F-4FC2-A1FF-6DC81B8B6F94]
>> First Option Software Ltd
>> Signal House
>> Jacklyns Lane
>> SO24 9JJ
>> Tel: +44 (0)1962 738232
>> Mob: +44 (0)7710 160458
>> Fax: +44 (0)1962 600112
>> Web: www.b <http://www.fosolutions.co.uk/>espokesoftware.com<http://bespokesoftware.com/>
>> This is confidential, non-binding and not company endorsed - see full
>> terms at www.fosolutions.co.uk/**emailpolicy.html<http://www.fosolutions.co.uk/emailpolicy.html>
>> First Option Software Ltd Registered No. 06340261
>> Signal House, Jacklyns Lane, Alresford, Hampshire, SO24 9JJ, U.K.
This is confidential, non-binding and not company endorsed - see full terms
First Option Software Ltd Registered No. 06340261
Signal House, Jacklyns Lane, Alresford, Hampshire, SO24 9JJ, U.K.