-Re: Bigtop Proposal
Konstantin Boudnik 2011-06-14, 18:38
Steve, 'functional' or rather system & integration tests are the core of this
idea. If you're interested in a little history of this project feel free to
that's basically the original idea/initial implementation (based on the work
done by Yahoo and known as HIT) which essentially lead to this proposal, I
believe (anyone please correct me if you found this suggestion wrong).
On Tue, Jun 14, 2011 at 01:33PM, Steve Loughran wrote:
> For those people who aren't on the Apache Incubator mailing lists, Tom
> White has proposed "BigTop", which is the tooling to integrate the build
> and testing of the Apache Hadoop technologies, perhaps eventually to
> have coordinated releases.
> For this to work, it needs support from all the hadoop-related projects
> in the ASF, and, in an ideal world, integration with those bits from
> outside (JUnit, Jetty) as well as downstream code (Cascading, etc). What
> is key is that the projects it builds and tests will need to care about
> the test failure reports, because BigTop should not be applying any
> patches to private branches of the specific projects (the way Cloudera
> and Ubuntu have done with the Hadoop and Linux source trees,
> respectively). Some kind of synchronized release schedule would be nice
> too, but I view that as a feature creep once the basic set up "build and
> test everything" is done.
> This could also be the place to put the functional tests against live
> clusters, tests which could eventually become the definition of
> compatibility that we've discussed before.
> For these reasons
> -I think everyone in the Hadoop-* projects dev teams ought to get
> involved, initially in reviewing the proposal, then hopefully on the
> mailing lists.
> -It might make sense for the hadoop, pig, hive, hama, mahout, hbase &c
> committers to all have access to this, so that they can help evolve the
> packaging and functional tests.