David Arthur 2012-08-03, 14:41
Jonathan Creasy 2012-08-03, 20:13
David Arthur 2012-08-06, 12:39
Jonathan Creasy 2012-08-06, 18:19
David Arthur 2012-08-10, 16:54
Jay Kreps 2012-08-10, 19:50
David Arthur 2012-08-11, 03:15
Taylor Gautier 2012-08-12, 14:39
David Arthur 2012-08-24, 16:37
Anyone have feedback on this approach?
On Aug 24, 2012, at 12:37 PM, David Arthur wrote:
> Here is an initial pass at a Kafka REST proxy (in Scala)
> The basic gist is:
> * Jetty for webserver
> * Messages are strings
> * GET /topic/group to get a message (timeout after 1s)
> * POST /topic, the request body is the message
> * One consumer thread per topic+group
> Be wary, many things are hard coded at this point (port numbers, etc). Obviously, this will need to change. Also, I haven't the slightest idea how to setup/use sbt properly, so I just checked in the libs.
> Feedback is welcome in this thread or on Github. Be gentle please, this is my first go at Scala
> On Aug 12, 2012, at 10:39 AM, Taylor Gautier wrote:
>> Jay I agree with you 100%.
>> At Tagged we have implemented a proxy for various internal reasons (
>> primarily to act as a high performance relay from PHP to Kafka). It's
>> Currently it services UDP packets encoded in binary but it could
>> easily be modified to accept http also since Node support for http is
>> pretty simple.
>> If others are interested in maintaining something like this we could
>> consider adding this to the public domain along side the already
>> existing Node.js client implementation.
>> On Aug 10, 2012, at 3:51 PM, Jay Kreps <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>>> My personal preference would be to have only a single protocol in kafka
>>> core. I have been down the multiple protocol route and my experience was
>>> that it adds a lot of burden for each change that needs to be made and a
>>> lot of complexity to abstract over the different protocols. From the point
>>> of view of a user they are generally a bit agnostic as to how bytes are
>>> sent back and forth provided it is reliable and easily implementable in any
>>> language. Generally they care more about the quality of the client in their
>>> language of choice.
>>> My belief is that the main benefit of REST is ease of implementing a
>>> client. But currently the biggest barrier is really the use of zk and
>>> fairly thick consumer design. So I think the current thinking is that we
>>> should focus on thinning that out and removing the client-side zk
>>> dependency. I actually don't think TCP is a huge burden if the protocol is
>>> simple, and there are actually some advantages (for example the consumer
>>> needs to consume from multiple servers so select/poll/epoll is natural but
>>> this is not always available from HTTP client libraries).
>>> Basically this is an area where I think it is best to pick one way and
>>> really make it really bullet proof rather than providing lots of options.
>>> In some sense each option tends to increase the complexity of testing
>>> (since now there are many combinations to try) and also of implementation
>>> (since now a lot things that were concrete now need to be abstracted away).
>>> So from this perspective I would prefer a standalone proxy that could
>>> evolve independently rather than retro-fitting the current socket server to
>>> handle other protocols. There will be some overhead for the extra hop, but
>>> then there is some overhead for HTTP itself.
>>> This is just my personal opinion, it would be great to hear what other
>>> On Mon, Aug 6, 2012 at 5:39 AM, David Arthur <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>>>> I'd be happy to collaborate on this, though it's been a while since I've
>>>> used PHP.
>>>> From what it looks like, what you have is a true proxy that runs outside
>>>> of Kafka and translates some REST routes into Kafka client calls. This
>>>> sounds more in line with what the project page describes. What I have
>>>> proposed is more like a translation layer between some REST routes and
>>>> FetchRequests. In this case the client is responsible for managing offsets.
David Arthur 2012-11-20, 21:08
David Arthur 2012-11-20, 22:06
Taylor Gautier 2012-11-21, 15:54