Home | About | Sematext search-lucene.com search-hadoop.com
 Search Hadoop and all its subprojects:

Switch to Threaded View
Hadoop >> mail # dev >> [PROPOSAL] change in bylaws to remove Release Plan vote

Copy link to this message
[PROPOSAL] change in bylaws to remove Release Plan vote
Hi all,
This has been a side topic in several email threads recently.  Currently we
have an ambiguity.  We have a tradition in the dev community that any
committer can create a branch, and propose release candidates from it.  Yet
the Hadoop bylaws say that releases have to be planned in advance, the plan
needs to be voted on, and presumably can be denied.

Apache policies (primarily here <http://www.apache.org/dev/release.html>
 and here <http://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html>, with
non-normative commentary
are very clear on how Releases have to be approved, and our bylaws are
consistent with those policies.  But Apache policies don't say anything
I've found about Release Plans, nor about voting on Release Plans.

I propose the following change, to remove Release Plan votes, and give a
simple definition of Release Manager role.  I'm opening discussion with
this proposal, and will put it to a vote if we seem to be getting
consensus.  Here's the changes I suggest in the

1. In the "Decision Making" : "Actions" section of the Bylaws, the
following text is removed:

** Release Plan*

Defines the timetable and actions for a release. The plan also nominates a
Release Manager.

Lazy majority of active committers
2. In the "Roles and Responsibilities" section of the Bylaws, an additional
role is defined:

** Release Manager*

A Release Manager (RM) is a committer who volunteers to produce a Release
Candidate according to
 The RM shall publish a Release Plan on the *common-dev@* list stating the
branch from which they intend to make a Release Candidate, at least one
week before they do so. The RM is responsible for building consensus around
the content of the Release Candidate, in order to achieve a successful
Product Release vote.

Please share your views.
Best regards,
--Matt (long-time release manager)